EU · appealed · ~9 min read
Apple — App Store music streaming (EU)
2020–present · app distribution on iOS, music streaming
Spotify and other music apps compete with Apple Music but must use Apple's App Store to reach iPhone users. Europe says Apple used its control of that store to block apps from telling you about cheaper prices on the web and to favor its own music service. Apple was fined, but arguments over App Store changes are still playing out.
The story
On iPhones, most apps are installed through Apple's App Store. Apple charges developers a commission on many digital purchases and sets detailed rules on payments and marketing.
Music streaming services complained they pay Apple a cut on subscriptions while Apple Music does not face the same fee. Worse, they said, Apple banned them from mentioning lower prices available on their websites.
The European Commission concluded Apple abused a dominant position in iOS app distribution for music streaming by applying anti-steering rules that distorted competition.
Parallel EU Digital Markets Act duties now require Apple to offer more choice in the EU—alternative app marketplaces, link-outs, and default app controls—though implementation remains contested.
Why it matters
App store rules decide whether small developers can reach customers without paying a platform tax.
Anti-steering bans affect what price information you see inside apps you already use.
The case connects classic abuse-of-dominance law with new DMA gatekeeper regulation.
What was claimed
Apple dominates distribution of music streaming apps on iOS.
Mandatory in-app payment and anti-steering rules raised rival costs and limited consumer choice.
Apple's conduct was not justified by security or quality arguments alone.
The other side
Apple says its App Store protects users from fraud and malware.
It argues the commission is wrong on market definition and that developers benefit from Apple's ecosystem.
Apple maintains it is complying with EU law while challenging aspects of enforcement.
What it means for you
EU iPhone users may see more links to external payment options and alternative app stores over time.
Subscription prices reflect platform fees—even when you never notice the App Store layer.
Ongoing compliance reviews mean the practical experience may keep changing.
Bottom line
Europe fined Apple €1.84 billion in March 2024 over music-app steering. Apple's court challenge is the live part; the DMA store case is a separate file.
Timeline
2020
Spotify complaint triggers EU probe
Streaming rivals argued Apple's App Store rules forced them to pay a 30% commission and banned telling users about cheaper web sign-ups.
2021–2023
Charges and DMA overlap
The Commission advanced abuse-of-dominance charges while new EU gatekeeper rules began applying to Apple.
2024–ongoing
Fine and compliance fights
Apple was fined and ordered to change rules, but disputes continue over whether DMA and App Store updates truly open competition.
Key dates
- EC opened App Store probe
- June 2020
- Statement of Objections (music)
- April 2021
- Infringement decision and fine
- March 4, 2024
Formal snapshot
Summary: The European Commission fined Apple €1.84 billion in March 2024 for App Store rules that kept music apps from telling users about cheaper offers outside the store. Apple challenged that decision.
Regulator / plaintiff argument: Anti-steering rules and mandatory in-app payment tied distribution to Apple's payment system, raising costs for rivals like Spotify and limiting consumer information.
Outcome: Commission fined Apple €1.84 billion in 2024 for music streaming-related abuses; DMA gatekeeper obligations and compliance monitoring continue.
Remedies: End anti-steering restrictions for music streaming apps; DMA requires broader choice screens and sideloading options on iOS in the EU.
Conduct tags
Laws referenced
- TFEU Article 102 — Art. 102 TFEU
- Digital Markets Act — Reg. (EU) 2022/1925
Companies
Reader signals
0 reads · synced via local demo storage — add NEXT_PUBLIC_SUPABASE_* to enable shared likes and comments
Comments
No comments yet — start the thread.